What Makes Olive Oil “Extra Virgin”—And Why Most Brands Are Lying

Updated on
What Makes Olive Oil “Extra Virgin”—And Why Most Brands Are Lying

🫒 What Makes Olive Oil “Extra Virgin”—And Why Most Brands Are Lying

TL;DR:
Most olive oils labeled “extra virgin” are anything but. Between shady supply chains, chemical processing, and mislabeling, the majority of oils on store shelves don’t meet the true standard of extra virgin. Here's how to tell if your olive oil is real—and why The Immortal passes the test.


🏛️ What Is Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Really?

The term “extra virgin” is legally defined in the EU and USDA as olive oil that is:

  1. Cold-pressed (extracted mechanically, no heat or chemicals)

  2. Unrefined (no chemical deodorizing or bleaching)

  3. Free from sensory defects (must taste fresh, fruity, and balanced)

  4. Low in free acidity (≤ 0.8%, a chemical marker of freshness)

It’s the highest grade of olive oil you can get—basically the first pure juice of the olive fruit.


💀 Why Most “Extra Virgin” Olive Oil Is Fake

Studies have shown that up to 70–80% of imported EVOO in U.S. grocery stores fail to meet these standards.

Why?

  • Oils are blended with cheaper refined oils (canola, soybean, or lower-grade olive oil)

  • “Cold-pressed” is used as marketing—but the oil was heated or chemically extracted

  • Bottles sit in hot shipping containers for months, degrading quality before reaching shelves

  • Fake oils still pass because regulations are rarely enforced in the U.S.

🧪 A UC Davis study tested 186 store-bought “extra virgin” olive oils.
69% failed the extra virgin test due to rancidity, poor taste, or adulteration.


⚠️ Clues You’re Being Lied To

🔍 Red Flag ❌ What It Means
Vague origin like “Product of Italy” Often a blend from multiple countries
Plastic bottle Allows light and oxygen to degrade oil
No harvest date or testing info Could be years old or blended
Super low price Real EVOO costs more—it's labor-intensive and limited

🛡 How to Tell If Your Olive Oil Is Real

Look for single origin: One specific farm or region
Dark glass or tin packaging: Protects oil from oxidation
Harvest date + lab test info: Transparency is key
Tastes alive: Real EVOO has a peppery bite or grassy edge
Certified by 3rd party: COOC, IOC, or regional certifications


🌿 Why The Immortal Is Truly Extra Virgin

At The Immortal, we obsess over purity and performance. Every bottle:

  • Comes from a single Spanish estate in Granada

  • Is cold-pressed within hours of harvest

  • Is unblended, unrefined, and unfiltered

  • Is bottled in dark UV-blocking glass

  • Includes third-party testing and a certificate of authenticity

  • Delivers up to 10x the polyphenol content of store-bought oil

This isn’t grocery store oil. It’s sacred fuel.


🧬 Why It Matters: Health, Flavor, and Ritual

Fake or refined oils are nutritionally dead and often inflammatory. Real extra virgin olive oil contains:

  • Polyphenols that fight oxidation, reduce inflammation, and protect the brain

  • Monounsaturated fats that support metabolic health and hormone balance

  • Enzymes and micronutrients you won’t find in refined oils

Plus, it just tastes alive—grassy, peppery, luxurious. Like it came from Olympus itself.


🛒 How to Make the Switch

You don’t need to overhaul your entire kitchen.
Just replace your default oil with real EVOO, and let your body feel the difference.

👉 Shop The Immortal EVOO – Buy One, Gift One Free

Updated on